What Secure Score is
Secure Score lives in the Microsoft Defender portal and counts how many of Microsoft's recommended security settings you've turned on. Each recommendation is worth up to 10 points. Most are all or nothing; some give partial points, for example when half your people are covered. You can mark a recommendation as resolved another way, which earns its points, or accept the risk, which earns none. You see recommendations for the Microsoft products you're licensed for. It shows your score over time and compares it with similar organizations.
Microsoft is clear about what it isn't: "It isn't an absolute measurement of how likely your system or data could be breached", and its recommendations "don't cover all the attack surfaces associated with each product".
Side by side
TenantWard shows your Secure Score and Microsoft's own comparison with similar companies next to its own checks, and links to Microsoft's list rather than copying it.
- Price: Secure Score is included with Microsoft 365. TenantWard has a free domain check and a Free plan; Protect is from $99 a month per company.
- What it measures against: Secure Score uses Microsoft's list of recommendations. TenantWard uses a baseline you decide, setting by setting, with a reason recorded for every exception.
- A domain's email security (SPF, DKIM, DMARC, MTA-STS, lookalikes) before anything is connected: Secure Score needs your Microsoft 365. TenantWard checks any domain, no account needed.
- Google Workspace: Secure Score doesn't cover it. TenantWard has admin, sign-in, sharing, email and domain checks and fixes.
- Making the change: with Secure Score you make it in the relevant admin center. TenantWard makes it in one click from a catalog of tested changes, with a plan, a backup and an undo.
- Settings changed behind your back: Secure Score shows it once Microsoft picks up the change, usually within a day or two. On Protect, TenantWard notices within minutes and puts it back to your baseline or raises it for a decision; lower plans check less often.
- Signs of an attack (a hijacked mailbox, a forwarding rule added today): Secure Score measures settings, not activity; alerts live elsewhere in Microsoft Defender. TenantWard checks every 15 minutes on Protect, with an optional automatic lockdown.
- Proof for an insurer or customer: Secure Score gives a score and a history. TenantWard answers insurance forms and questionnaires from the live setup, with evidence (Comply).
- Who it's written for: Secure Score is for IT and security staff. TenantWard is written for owners and office managers, with more detail for IT providers.
When Secure Score is enough
- You have someone technical who works through the recommendations in the Defender portal and knows which ones are worth the disruption for a company your size.
- Someone already watches for compromised accounts and checks your domain's email records.
- Nobody outside the company asks you to prove any of it.
- If that's you, use Secure Score and our free domain check, and skip the rest.
When TenantWard adds something
- Nobody at the company can safely make the changes, or you want each one backed up with an undo.
- You need to know when a setting changes, not just see a lower score.
- Your insurer, a large customer or your board wants answers with evidence.
- You run Google Workspace, or both.
What TenantWard doesn't do
So the comparison is fair, a few things an outside review may check that TenantWard deliberately doesn't: Customer Lockbox (it needs Microsoft 365 E5 or an add-on, and it controls what Microsoft's own engineers can see), automatic sensitivity labels (they need Microsoft 365 E5 or an E5 compliance or information protection add-on), and administrative units (a 5 to 150 person company rarely has anyone to split admin work between). It also doesn't turn each Secure Score recommendation into its own issue.
Sources
- Microsoft Learn, Microsoft Secure Score: learn.microsoft.com/en-us/defender-xdr/microsoft-secure-score
- Microsoft Learn, Assess your security posture through Microsoft Secure Score: learn.microsoft.com/en-us/defender-xdr/microsoft-secure-score-improvement-actions
- Microsoft Learn, Track your Secure Score history: learn.microsoft.com/en-us/defender-xdr/microsoft-secure-score-history-metrics-trends
- Microsoft Learn, Microsoft Purview Customer Lockbox: learn.microsoft.com/en-us/purview/customer-lockbox-requests
Questions
- Does TenantWard replace Secure Score?
- No. It shows your Secure Score alongside its own checks. Secure Score is a good list of Microsoft's recommendations; TenantWard adds the changes themselves, the watching and the evidence.
See where your company stands
Check a domain for free. A free account also connects Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace read-only and shows every issue it finds; a plan shows who's affected and fixes it.